Comparison of Two Types of Education
Traditional (TYPE #1) vs. CSCOPE/Common Core Standards (TYPE #2)
Chart Produced by Carole H. Haynes, Ph.D.
Traditional Type #1 Classical Learning |
CSCOPE Type #2 Progressivism/Radical |
Common Core Standards Type #2 Progressivism/Radical Social Justice Agenda |
|
Instruction | Direct instruction by teacher | Self-directed learning, group-think |
Emphasis on subjectivity, feelings, emotions, beliefs, multiculturalism, political correctness, social engineering, globalism, evolution, sexual freedom, contraceptives, environmental extremism, global warming/climate change, victimization, diversity, acceptance of homosexuality as normal, & wealth redistribution.
De-emphasis on Declaration of Independence, Bill of Rights, Constitution, Founding Fathers, national sovereignty, and American exceptionalism. |
Curriculum | Academic, fact-based, skills, research |
Social concerns, project-based, constructivist, subjective, uses unproven fads and theories |
|
Teacher’s role |
Authority figure, sets the
plan for the class, academic instruction |
Facilitator |
|
Student’s role |
Learn from teacher, focus on factual learning, develop foundation skills for logical & analytical reasoning, independent thinking |
Students teach each other; focus on feelings, emotions, opinions; group-think |
|
English, Language Arts, Reading
(ELAR) |
Phonics; classical literature; cursive handwriting; grammar; usage; correct spelling; expository, persuasive, research writing |
Whole language, balanced literacy, Guided Reading; no cursive writing instruction so can’t read primary documents of Founding Fathers |
|
Math |
Drill and skill," four math functions learned to automaticity |
Fuzzy math, rejects drill and memorization of math facts, dependent on calculators |
|
Social Studies |
Focus on American heritage/ exceptionalism, national sovereignty, Founding Documents |
Diversity, multiculturalism, globalization, revisionist history, political correctness |
|
Character development |
Pro-faith, self control, personal responsibility, self-discipline, solid work ethic |
Secular, moral relativism, anti-faith, victimization |
|
Equality |
Equal opportunities |
Equal outcomes |
|
Assessment |
Students evaluated by earned grades, objective tests |
Inflated grades, subjective assessments, evaluated based upon the value-system of the grader |
|
Outcomes |
Objective tests (right or wrong answers), emphasis on academic skills and knowledge |
Subjective assessments; emphasis on holistic, "feel-good" scoring |
Find more information HERE